Talk with a deliverability expert

No need to flee, it's totally free

Understanding Seedlisting Results with Warmy's Seedlisting Feature
Daniel Shnaider
by Daniel Shnaider
Understanding Seedlisting Results with Warmy's Seedlisting Feature

Decoding Seedlisting Results using Warmy's Seedlisting Feature


Seedlisting tests are an invaluable tool for monitoring, evaluating and improving your email deliverability. Once you have conducted the tests using Warmy's seedlisting feature, it's crucial to understand the significance of the results and take appropriate actions. In this article, we'll explore various scenarios that may arise from seedlisting tests and provide you with actionable solutions to ensure optimal email deliverability.


When Things Look Good:


If your seedlisting results indicate that your emails are successfully reaching the inboxes of major email service providers and passing authentication checks, congratulations! However, maintaining good deliverability requires ongoing attention. Here's what you can do to maintain and enhance your email performance:


a. Monitor Performance Metrics. egularly track your email deliverability metrics, such as open rates, click-through rates, reply, and bounce rates on your end. This data will help you identify any potential fluctuations or issues that may arise in the future and keep you aware.


b. Test and Optimize. Continuously experiment with different subject lines, email content, and sending strategies to improve engagement and response rates. A/B testing can provide valuable insights into what resonates best with your audience.


c. Stay Compliant. Adhere to email best practices and follow industry guidelines to maintain a positive reputation as a sender. Respect opt-outs and unsubscribe requests promptly, and ensure that your email list is opt-in and properly segmented or targeted.


When Problems Are Detected Early:


Seedlisting results may occasionally provide early indicators of potential issues that could impact your email deliverability, revealing the onset of problems or a gradual decline in inbox placement rates. Catching these problems early allows you to address them proactively. Here's what to do if you detect early signs of trouble:


a. Investigate Authentication Failures. If your seedlisting results show authentication failures, such as SPF, DKIM, or DMARC issues, it's crucial to investigate and rectify them. Review your email authentication settings, consult relevant documentation or seek assistance from your email service provider, hosting provider or IT team to resolve any configuration errors.


b. Check for Spam Triggers. Examine your seedlisting results for signs of spam triggers. Identify any content or formatting elements that might trigger spam filters, such as excessive use of promotional language or multiple tracking links overlaid, suspicious links, etc. Adjust your email content accordingly to avoid potential filtering.


c. Analyze Inbox Placement. If your seedlisting results indicate inconsistent inbox placement across different email service providers, it is essential to delve into the factors influencing deliverability. Look for common patterns or similarities in the emails that didn't land in the primary inbox and make adjustments accordingly. Keep in mind that each mailbox provider employs its own set of criteria, including sender historical reputation, recipient engagement/behavior, and various flags, to determine email placement.


If Gmail starts classifying your emails as spam:


1. Review Content and Formatting. Examine your email content and formatting for any elements that may trigger Gmail's spam filters. Avoid using excessive promotional language, suspicious links, or attachments that could raise red flags. Ensure your emails provide value and align with Gmail's guidelines.


2. Check Sender Reputation. Monitor your sender reputation by checking if your IP addresses or domains have been blacklisted. Address any reputation issues promptly by following delisting procedures or working towards improving your sending practices.


3. Authentication and Compliance. Verify that your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication settings are correctly configured. Comply with Gmail's guidelines, including honoring opt-outs and providing clear unsubscribe options, to demonstrate your commitment to best practices.


If Yahoo starts classifying your emails as spam:


1. Sender Reputation Evaluation. Assess your sender reputation, as Yahoo also considers the sending history and domain reputation. Monitor blacklists and ensure your sending practices align with industry standards.


2. Engagement and Feedback Loops. Yahoo pays attention to user engagement and feedback loops. Analyze whether your emails are relevant and engaging to recipients. Encourage recipients to provide feedback or mark emails as "not spam" if they are legitimate.


3. Domain Authentication. Double-check your domain authentication settings (SPF, DKIM, and DMARC) to ensure they are properly configured. Consistent authentication improves trust and deliverability.


If AOL starts classifying your emails as spam:


1. Content and Formatting Review. Scrutinize your email content and formatting for any factors that may trigger AOL's spam filters. Optimize your emails to provide value, avoid excessive promotional language without making your content convoluted, and maintain a professional tone that shows value to the recipient.


2. IP and Domain Reputation. Monitor your IP and domain reputation, as AOL considers sender reputation when determining email placement. Take necessary steps to resolve any reputation issues and improve your sending practices.


3. Feedback and Complaint Handling. Pay attention to feedback and complaints from AOL users. Promptly address any issues raised and make improvements based on user feedback to enhance deliverability.


If Microsoft starts classifying your emails as spam:


1. Sender Authentication. Ensure your emails pass Microsoft's authentication checks (SPF, DKIM, and DMARC). Proper authentication builds trust and increases the chances of your emails landing in the inbox.


2. Content Quality and Relevance. Examine your email content for quality and relevance. Avoid deceptive subject lines, suspicious links, or misleading information that could trigger Microsoft's spam filters. Tailor your emails to provide value to recipients.


3. Complaint and Reputation Monitoring. Stay vigilant about any complaints or reputation issues associated with your sending IP addresses or domains. Regularly monitor blacklists and address any problems promptly.


If iCloud starts classifying your emails as spam:


1. Sender Reputation Evaluation. Evaluate your sender reputation, as iCloud takes sender history into account. Monitor blacklists and ensure your sending practices adhere to best practices. Be honest with your sending practices and strategies and make necessary changes before it is too late.


2. User Engagement and Feedback. Focus on improving user engagement by delivering valuable content to iCloud users. Encourage recipients to mark your emails as "not spam" if they are legitimate. Actively address user feedback and complaints.


3. Authentication and Compliance. Verify that your emails are properly authenticated with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. Comply with iCloud's guidelines and industry standards to improve deliverability.


It's important to acknowledge that mailbox providers have mechanisms in place to detect unsolicited or cold email practices. While seedlisting results provide valuable insights into deliverability, it's crucial to understand that sending cold emails is not in line with the terms and conditions of most mailbox providers. Rather than focusing on reaching as many people as possible, the best approach for long-term success is to shift towards sending emails to current customers and consent-based recipients. By targeting a narrow audience with tailored messages, you can enhance engagement and avoid potential spam filters.


Building a strong reputation and maintaining compliance should be a priority. Instead of sending long series of emails, focus on delivering valuable content and making it easy for recipients to unsubscribe. Providing an effortless unsubscribe process helps recipients manage their email preferences and reduces the likelihood of them marking your emails as spam which affects your deliverability and inboxing rates.


In summary, it's essential to align your email practices with the recipient's expectations and mailbox provider guidelines. By targeting consent-based recipients, delivering relevant content, and respecting unsubscribe requests, you can establish positive relationships with both recipients and mailbox providers, resulting in improved email deliverability and long-term success.


Dealing with Bad Results:


Seedlisting results that consistently show poor inbox placement, authentication failures, or being flagged as spam require immediate attention. Here's what you can do to tackle such challenges:


1. Investigate Sender Reputation. If you notice your emails are not landing in the inbox or being blocked, start by checking when the issues started. Look for any significant changes in your sending practices, infrastructure, or content that could have affected your sender reputation. Understanding the root cause is crucial for implementing the right solutions.


2. Authentication Setup. Ensure that your email authentication protocols, such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, are properly configured. These protocols help verify your identity as a legitimate sender. It doesn’t matter if you are a small or large-volume sender. Protecting your domain is extremely important. Authenticating all the way to DMARC will allow you to protect your sender domains and sub-domains and alert you when unknown sources are sending emails with your sender identity.


Here are some resources for implementing authentication:


◾ Gmail: Authentication Guidelines

◾ Yahoo & AOL: DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM)

◾ Microsoft: DKIM, SPF & DMARC


3. Evaluate Sending Infrastructure. Assess the health and configuration of your sending infrastructure, including your email server, IP addresses, and domains. Make sure they adhere to industry standards and best practices.


4. Content Quality and Compliance. Review your email content for quality, relevance, and compliance with anti-spam guidelines. Avoid deceptive subject lines, excessive promotional language, or misleading information that may trigger spam filters.


5. List Hygiene. Utilize multiple list hygiene tools such as Bouncer, KickBox, ZeroBounce to regularly clean and manage your email lists. Different tools check a different set of list hygiene checks. Remove undeliverable, unknown, risky, inactive or unengaged recipients to maintain a healthy and engaged subscriber base. List hygiene tools can help automate this process, but will not be able to find all issues. It is impossible to remove all spam traps, emails that will bounce or predict if a recipient will click on “this is spam” button.


6. Complaint Handling. Actively address user complaints and unsubscribe requests. Provide clear and easy-to-find unsubscribe options in your emails, allowing recipients to manage their preferences effectively.


7. Engagement and Sender-Recipient Relationship. Build positive relationships with your recipients by sending targeted and relevant emails to engaged subscribers who have provided consent. Encourage recipients to whitelist your email address or add you to their contacts.


8. ISP-Specific Guidelines. Familiarize yourself with the guidelines and policies of major mailbox providers. Here are the relevant links for each:


◾ Gmail: Gmail Postmaster Tools

◾ Yahoo & AOL: Yahoo & AOL Mail Postmaster

◾ Microsoft: Microsoft Postmaster

◾ iCloud: iCloud Mail Postmaster


9. Reputation Repair. If your sender reputation has suffered, consider consulting with deliverability experts or hiring deliverability consultants. They can provide guidance and assistance in resolving reputation issues effectively.


10. Deliverability Monitoring. Utilize deliverability monitoring tools to track email delivery, bounce rates, and spam placement. These tools help identify patterns and issues that need to be addressed to improve deliverability so that the next time you are aware and can fix issues before they become detrimental.


By following these steps, investigating the issues with your sender reputation, and implementing the necessary improvements, you can work towards improving your email deliverability. Changing domains might help solve the issue temporarily, but if sender practices aren’t changed, the same issues will remain and impact your inboxing. The more you rotate IPs or domains the easier it becomes for spam filters to understand you are snowshoeing. Remember that seeking professional advice from deliverability consultants and utilizing list hygiene tools can further enhance your chances of successfully reaching the recipient's inbox.


Overall, seedlisting results offer valuable insights into your email deliverability performance. Whether the results are positive, indicate early signs of trouble, or reveal significant issues, taking appropriate action is crucial. By monitoring key metrics, optimizing your email content and delivery strategies, resolving authentication failures, and proactively managing your sender reputation, you can ensure optimal email deliverability. Remember, addressing potential deliverability challenges early on is the key to maintaining a positive sender reputation and maximizing the effectiveness of your email campaigns.


📜 Related article:

Supercharge Your Email Deliverability with Warmy's Seedlisting Feature

◾ Email Authentication: Unlocking the Secrets Email Deliverability

How to improve deliverability with email deliverability tools