Warmy Blog

Preparing Your Mailbox for a Large-Scale Cold Outreach Campaign

Talk with a deliverability expert!

No need to flee, it’s totally free


    Are you preparing to launch a large-scale cold outreach campaign? 

    While the excitement of embarking on this new venture can quickly become overwhelming, it is essential that you take the time to adequately prepare your mailbox first. 

    Cold outreach campaigns involve sending out bulk emails to prospects who may not be aware of your business or are passively interested in what you have to offer. 

    By taking steps now and setting an appropriate foundation for your future efforts, you will be well placed for long term success. In this blog post we’ll discuss a few things that should be considered when readying up your mailbox for a cold outreach campaign.

    Step 1. Preparing an email domain for cold outreach

    Register a New Domain

    When it comes to successful cold outreach, creating a strong email domain is crucial. Rather than using an existing domain, we highly advise purchasing a new one specifically for this purpose. Not only will this increase your chances of avoiding spam filters, but it also looks more professional and legitimate to potential recipients.

    By investing in a new domain, you have the opportunity to choose a name that reflects your brand image and messaging. This gives you the chance to craft a more personalized email experience for each recipient you reach out to, as well as establish credibility and authority in your industry. Additionally, using a dedicated domain for cold outreach helps you to keep your personal correspondence separate from your professional communications.

    Domain extensions

    Domain extensions, also known as top-level domains (TLDs), are the last segment of a domain name that comes after the dot (“.”) symbol. For example, in the domain name “example.com,” “.com” is the domain extension.

    There are two main types of domain extensions: generic top-level domains (gTLDs) and country code top-level domains (ccTLDs).

    ✅ gTLDs are generic extensions that are not associated with a specific country or geographic location. Some examples of gTLDs include “.com”, “.org”, “.net”, and “.info”. These extensions are open for registration by anyone worldwide.

    ✅ ccTLDs, on the other hand, are country-specific domain extensions that are associated with a specific geographic location. Examples of ccTLDs include “.us” for the United States, “.ca” for Canada, “.uk” for the United Kingdom, and “.fr” for France. These extensions are usually reserved for businesses or individuals residing in the corresponding country.

    Generally, gTLDs fall under the categories of commercial, organizational, network, and informational.

    Commercial gTLDs are intended for businesses engaged in commerce, such as those in the retail and service industries. These extensions include .com, .net, and .biz.

    Organizational gTLDs are meant for non-commercial organizations such as charities, schools, and government entities. Examples of these include .org, .edu, and .gov.

    Network gTLDs are primarily used by internet service providers and network infrastructure companies. These extensions include .arpa and .int.

    Finally, informational gTLDs are intended for websites providing information or resources, such as news outlets and online libraries. Examples of informational gTLDs include .info and .mobi.

    While these categories aren’t as strictly enforced as they were in the past, it’s still important to consider the type of business you’re running and choose a domain extension that aligns with your brand and messaging. By doing so, you can create a more cohesive online presence and make it easier for potential customers to find and remember your website.

    It’s also worth noting that there are newer gTLDs available that may be more relevant to your business or industry. For example, there are extensions like .tech, .design, and .online that may be more specific and memorable for certain businesses. It’s important to weigh all your options and choose the extension that best serves your needs and goals.

    ❗ One way to safeguard a brand’s reputation is by purchasing a domain name that is similar to the existing brand domain. For instance, if a brand’s domain name is “mybrand.com,” purchasing “mybrand.net” or “mybrand.org” can help prevent others from using similar domain names to deceive customers, damage the brand’s image, or steal its traffic.

    And one more important question that our clients often ask - are paid email accounts better than free ones? The short answer is yes!

    Whether it is for personal or professional communication, email usage is ubiquitous. When it comes to cold email outreach, one of the most pressing concerns for individuals and businesses alike is whether paid email accounts are better compared to free ones.

    While free email services provide users with a basic email solution, paid email accounts often come bundled with additional benefits such as increased storage space, advanced security features, and customer support. 

    For instance, some paid email account providers offer spam protection that helps filter out unsolicited emails, thereby minimizing the risk of phishing attacks. Additionally, paid email accounts usually have a higher level of encryption, protecting the sender’s privacy and personal information.

    Moreover, when it comes to cold email outreach, paid email accounts can lend greater credibility and professionalism to your messages. Sending an email from a business domain name, for example, increases the likelihood of your email being opened and taken seriously. This can be especially important for individuals or businesses that rely heavily on cold email outreach as a crucial part of their marketing strategy.

    Furthermore, with paid email accounts, you are often able to access features like email tracking and analytics. These tools can provide you with insights into whether your emails are being opened, who is opening them, and how recipients are responding to your emails. Such information can be valuable for improving future email campaigns.

    Step 2. Setting up crucial configurations for successful cold emailing campaigns


    1. To begin with, it is important to ensure your email provider has enabled the sending of bulk emails, otherwise, the campaign may be halted before it even begins.

    2. Another crucial configuration to set up for a successful cold emailing campaign is the deployment of email autoresponders. Autoresponders are essentially automated emails that are sent in response to certain trigger actions, such as opening an email or clicking on a link in an email. Setting up autoresponders that convey an appropriate message to recipients can help to establish credibility and increase the chances of engagement.

    3. When preparing your mailbox for a large-scale cold outreach campaign, it is important to ensure that you have set up crucial configurations for successful cold emailing campaigns. This includes configuring SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records in your DNS and ensuring that your mailbox is set up with the correct A Record, CNAME Record, and MX Record.

    🔹 SPF (Sender Policy Framework) is a type of email authentication that is used to prevent email spoofing. It allows you to specify which IP addresses are allowed to send email on behalf of your domain, thus preventing unauthorized parties from forging your email address. This is important because it helps to ensure that your emails actually reach your recipients and that they are not flagged as spam.

    🔹 DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) is another type of email authentication that works by using cryptographic keys to verify that messages are authentic. This helps to prevent phishing and spoofing attacks, and it can also improve your deliverability rates.

    🔹 DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance) is a policy that helps to prevent email fraud by giving domain owners the ability to specify how email from their domain should be handled. It allows you to set policies that specify how email that is not authentic should be handled, and it can also help to improve your deliverability rates by providing feedback on your email authentication status.

    🔹 In addition to setting up these crucial email authentication records, it is also important to ensure that your mailbox is properly configured with the correct A Record, CNAME Record, and MX Record. The A Record maps your domain name to the IP address of your email server, while the CNAME Record maps your domain name to another domain name. The MX Record specifies the hostnames of the mail servers that are responsible for delivering mail to your domain.

    4. Finally, it is important to optimize various email settings, such as the email signature, subject line, and email copy. The email signature should feature clear contact information, while the subject line should be captivating and attention-grabbing. The email copy should be concise and compelling, with a clear call-to-action that encourages the recipient to take the desired action.

    These crucial configurations, when implemented properly, can significantly boost the success of your cold emailing campaign and help to maximize your outreach efforts.

    Step 3. Properly warming up your domain to improve the deliverability of your cold emails

    email deliverability test

    Warming up your domain is vital to the success of your cold outreach campaign and one of the best ways to ensure your emails reach their intended recipients is by utilizing Warmy.io. This platform offers a comprehensive solution for improving the deliverability of your emails by gradually building up your email reputation and reducing the risk of your messages being classified as spam.

    One of the key benefits of using Warmy.io is that it offers a range of warming-up plans that are tailored to meet the unique needs of your specific domain. This means that you can choose the right plan that aligns with your outreach strategy, and ensures that your emails are delivered to your prospects’ inboxes, as opposed to their spam folder.

    Warmy.io also provides a range of tools and features designed to help you manage your email campaigns effectively. This includes advanced analytics, Email deliverability checker, email health checker, free email template checker.

    Another key benefit of using Warmy.io is that it offers a range of methods to warm up your domain, including SMTP warmup, Domain warmup, and IP warmup. This level of flexibility ensures that you can choose the right warming-up strategy, based on your specific needs and preferences.

    Overall, using Warmy.io is an essential step to consider when preparing your mailbox for a large-scale cold outreach campaign. Its powerful features, tailored plans, and range of warming-up methods can ensure that your emails are delivered effectively, helping you to achieve better results and higher open rates.

    Step 4. Launching your cold email campaign with confidence. Step by step


    Launching a cold email campaign with confidence requires careful planning and execution. Here are some step-by-step guidelines to help you launch your cold email campaign:

    1. Identify the specific group of people you want to target with your cold emails. Make sure they align with your ideal customer profile and are likely to be interested in your offer. 

    2. Once you have defined your target audience, build a list of relevant email addresses. You can use various tools and resources such as LinkedIn, and professional directories, or purchase email lists from reputable providers. One of the best tools right now is – AnyBiz.io

    3. Craft a personalized and well-crafted email that resonates with your target audience. Ensure that it is concise, clear, and offers some value to the recipient.

    4. Before sending your email, test it to ensure that it is delivered successfully, looks professional, and contains no errors. You can use tools like Grammarly or Hemingway to check for grammar and spelling errors.

    5. Once you have tested your email, it’s time to launch your campaign. Make sure to schedule your emails at the right time for your target audience, keeping in mind their time zones and work schedules. Don’t forget to write at least 3 follow-up emails.

    6. Keep track of your email campaign’s performance by monitoring metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and reply rates. This will help you evaluate the success of your campaign and make adjustments for future campaigns.

    7. Follow up with your prospects who have shown interest in your offer. This can help you build relationships with potential customers and increase your chances of closing deals.

    Cold email follow up best practices

    Cold email follow-up is an essential part of any cold email campaign. It helps to increase the chances of converting prospects into customers. 

    1. Plan a follow-up sequence in advance that includes multiple touchpoints over several weeks. This helps to keep your message top-of-mind and increases the chances of getting a response.

    The number of follow-up emails you should send in a cold email campaign depends on several factors, including your industry, target audience, and the nature of your offer. However, most experts recommend sending at least 3-4 follow-up emails after your initial cold email.

    ✔ First follow-up: Send the first follow-up email 2-3 days after your initial email.

    ✔ Second follow-up: If you don’t receive a response to your first follow-up, send a second follow-up email 4-5 days after the first one.

    ✔ Third follow-up: If you still don’t receive a response after the second follow-up, send a third follow-up email 7-10 days after the second one.

    ✔ Fourth follow-up: If you still don’t receive a response after the third follow-up, send a fourth and final follow-up email 14-21 days after the third one.

    2. Avoid sending generic follow-up messages. Instead, personalize your messages by mentioning the recipient’s name, referring to their specific pain points, and reminding them of your previous email.

    3. Keep your follow-up messages brief and to the point. Use bullet points, subheadings, and bold text to highlight important information.

    4. Offer something of value in every follow-up email, such as a free trial, demo, or case study. This helps to demonstrate your expertise and build trust with your prospects.

    5. It’s important to be persistent in your follow-up efforts, but avoid being pushy or aggressive. Respect your prospects’ time and avoid sending too many follow-up emails.

    6. Don’t rely on email alone for follow-up. Consider using other channels like LinkedIn, Twitter, or phone calls to reach out to your prospects.

    📜 Related article:

    ◾ Why Do You Need to Configure SPF, DKIM, DMARC and How To Set Them
    ◾ The Importance of a Domain in Cold Email Marketing 
    ◾ Cold Email Follow up Templates


    Now that you have taken the time to properly prepare your mailbox for a large-scale cold outreach campaign, it’s time to test it out. By following the tips outlined here, you will be well on your way to maximizing both the reach and efficacy of your cold outreach initiatives.

    As email remains an essential communication tool for businesses everywhere, having strategies in place that can undoubtedly increase engagement is invaluable. Of course, keep testing different approaches and attempting to learn from past mistakes in order to optimize your efforts moving forward.

    With the right strategy and execution steps in motion, you’ll certainly be able to benefit from such a powerful outreach channel without overwhelming your team. All that’s left now is for you to take action, tweak where needed, and watch your bottom line blossom as a result!

    Ready to take your email campaigns to the next level? The first step is warming up your domain with Warmy.io! Our email warm-up process is designed to gradually increase email activity from your domain and build a positive sending reputation with email service providers.

    With an increased reputation, your emails are more likely to reach the inbox and avoid the spam folder. Don’t let poor sender reputation affect your campaigns – start warming up your domain today with Warmy.io!

    Scroll to Top