Talk with a deliverability expert

No need to flee, it's totally free

A Guide to Email Campaign Performance Indicators
Inna Sabada
by Inna Sabada
A Guide to Email Campaign Performance Indicators

A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding and Measuring Key Performance Indicators for Successful Email Marketing Campaigns


Whether you’re just getting started with email marketing or have been running campaigns for years, it’s essential to make sure that your emails are delivering the right message and connecting with your target audience. 


To do this effectively, there is one key factor that any successful email marketer must consider: measurement. But what exactly should be measured? How can performance indicators help you identify potential areas of improvement?


If decoding metrics isn’t part of your skill set yet, don’t fret – in this guide to email campaign performance indicators, we will unravel the mysteries of measurement and equip you with valuable tips on how to use those findings to enhance your campaigns.



Importance of email campaign performance indicators


Click-Through Rates


Email campaigns serve as an essential tool for businesses to promote their products and services. The success of these campaigns is determined by several performance indicators, which provide invaluable insights into the effectiveness and reach of the campaign. These metrics are essential in assessing the efficacy of the email campaigns, whether the objective was to generate leads, expand brand awareness, or foster customer loyalty.


Open rate, click-through rate, conversion rate, and unsubscribe rate are some of the primary performance indicators used to assess the success of email campaigns. Of these, the open rate determines the number of recipients who opened the marketing email, while the click-through rate calculates the percentage of people who clicked on a link within an email. These two indicators give an idea of whether or not the email's content resonated with the audience, and effective ways to improve click-through rates are enticing subject lines and calls-to-action.


In contrast, the conversion rate measures the percentage of people who completed a desired action, such as making a purchase or filling out a form. This metric is valuable in assessing how persuasive the email copy and call-to-action are. Finally, the unsubscribe rate counts the number of subscribers who opted out of receiving future emails - an indicator of dissatisfaction or disinterest.


Such performance indicators are essential to improve and optimize future email campaigns. Monitoring these metrics can highlight areas that need improvement and allow businesses to adjust their marketing strategies and messaging. In turn, this will lead to more targeted and personalized emails, with increased engagement and response rates.


In conclusion, performance indicators play a crucial role in showing businesses how well their email campaigns are performing and assessing their effectiveness. By paying close attention to these metrics, businesses can continually improve their email marketing strategies, providing more valuable content to their subscribers, and ultimately generate financial returns.



Key Email Campaign Metrics to Track


#1 Email Open Rate


Open rates are one of the most commonly used email campaign performance indicators by marketers. It is a metric that shows the percentage of emails that were opened by the recipients. This metric is important because it helps marketers understand how effective their email campaigns are at grabbing the attention of their subscribers and encouraging them to engage with the content.


The calculation of open rates is based on the number of times an email is opened by the recipients, divided by the total number of emails that were delivered. The result is usually presented as a percentage, with a high open rate indicating that the email campaign has been successful in engaging the subscribers and driving traffic to the website.


However, it is important to note that open rates can sometimes be misleading. For example, if an email client downloads images automatically, the email may be recorded as opened even if the subscriber did not actively engage with the content. Additionally, some subscribers may have set their email clients to automatically mark emails as read, which would also skew the open rates.


Despite these potential flaws, open rates are still valuable metrics for email campaigns. Marketers can use this metric to track the success of email subject lines, the timing of delivery, and the relevance of content to their target audience. By analyzing the open rates of different email campaigns, marketers can make more informed decisions about how to optimize their email marketing strategies and improve their overall performance.



Email Open Rate Formula


Open Rates: (Number of email opens / Number of emails delivered) x 100



#2 Click-Through Rates


Click-through rates are one of the most crucial email campaign performance indicators. They indicate the percentage of recipients who clicked on a link within an email. A high click-through rate is indicative of email engagement and can be an excellent measure of the effectiveness of an email campaign.


The average click-through rate for email campaigns varies by industry, but a rate of 2.5% is considered acceptable across all sectors. However, it's important to note that a high click-through rate doesn't always guarantee a high conversion rate; it just means that the recipient showed enough interest to click on the link.


Factors that influence the click-through rate include the quality of the email content, the relevance of the email to the recipient, and the call-to-action (CTA) used. For instance, using an eye-catching CTA and making sure the email content aligns with the recipient's interests can significantly increase the click-through rate.


To optimize click-through rates, it's essential to conduct continuous A/B testing to identify what works best for your specific audience. The results can help you refine your email marketing strategy and produce more effective campaigns in the future.


Click-Through Rates Formula


Click-Through Rates: (Number of clicks on links / Number of emails delivered) x 100



#3 Conversion Rates


Conversion rates are one of the most important email campaign performance indicators to monitor, as they measure how many recipients took the desired action after receiving an email. This action could be anything from making a purchase to filling out a form or downloading a resource. A high conversion rate indicates that the email content was compelling and relevant enough to persuade the recipients to take the desired action.


Conversion rates are calculated by dividing the number of recipients who took the desired action by the total number of emails delivered. For example, if an email campaign resulted in 100 conversions out of 1,000 delivered emails, the conversion rate would be 10%.


It’s important to note that conversion rates vary widely by industry, type of email, and desired action. For example, a promotional email campaign may have a higher conversion rate for purchases than a newsletter with educational content.


To improve conversion rates, email marketers should focus on creating relevant and personalized content that speaks to the recipients’ interests and pain points. Split testing different elements of the email, such as subject lines, calls to action, and offers, can also help identify which factors are most effective at driving conversions.


Finally, tracking conversion rates over time can help evaluate the effectiveness of email campaigns and optimize future efforts for even better results.


Conversion Rates Formula


Conversion Rates: (Number of people who completed desired action / Number of emails delivered) x 100



#4 Bounce Rates


Bounce rates are an important email campaign performance indicator that measures the percentage of email addresses that do not receive your message due to a variety of reasons, such as full inboxes, temporary email server issues, incorrect email addresses, and spam filters.


A high bounce rate can indicate an issue with your email list quality, the relevancy of your message to your audience, or even the technical aspects of your email campaign. If you have a consistently high bounce rate, it can damage your sender reputation and impact the deliverability of future email campaigns.


There are two types of bounces: hard and soft. A hard bounce occurs when an email is returned due to a permanent issue, such as an invalid email address or a closed account. On the other hand, a soft bounce happens when an email is returned due to a temporary issue, such as a full inbox or a technical problem with the recipient's email server.


It's important to monitor and analyze your bounce rate regularly to ensure that your email list is healthy and engaged with your brand. You can reduce your bounce rate by regularly cleaning your email list, segmenting your audience based on interests and behaviors, and using a double opt-in process to confirm email addresses.


Overall, bounce rates are an essential email campaign performance metric that can indicate the health of your email list and help improve the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts.


Bounce Rates Formula


Bounce Rates: (Number of emails bounced / Number of emails sent) x 100



#5 Unsubscribe Rates


Unsubscribe rates are a significant performance indicator for email campaigns as they provide valuable insight into the effectiveness of email marketing efforts. The unsubscribe rate refers to the percentage of email recipients who opt-out of receiving future emails from a brand. While high unsubscribe rates may seem discouraging, they serve as a tell-tale sign of the quality of the email content, frequency of emails, and relevance to the target audience.


Research shows that the average unsubscribe rate across all industries is around 0.17%. However, this rate can vary depending on various factors such as the type of industry, email content, and audience segments. A higher rate could be a result of sending too many emails, irrelevant content, or a poorly segmented audience. On the other hand, a low unsubscribe rate could indicate that subscribers find the content valuable and relevant.


Marketers can use unsubscribe rates to fine-tune their email marketing techniques. By analyzing the rate, marketers can identify issues and make modifications to their campaigns. This may include changing the frequency of emails or targeting a specific audience segment. Ultimately, by monitoring the unsubscribe rates, marketers can optimize their campaigns to improve performance and build stronger relationships with subscribers.


In conclusion, unsubscribe rates are a crucial email campaign performance metric that can provide critical insights into the effectiveness of email marketing strategies. Analyzing this metric can help marketers understand how to fine-tune their campaigns to build better relationships with subscribers and improve overall campaign performance.


Unsubscribe Rates Formula


Unsubscribe Rates: (Number of unsubscribes / Number of emails delivered) x 100



#6 List Growth Rates


List Growth Rates are an important metric for evaluating the success of your email campaigns. This metric indicates the rate at which your email list is expanding over a specific period of time. It helps you to monitor the progress of your email marketing efforts and to identify potential opportunities for improving your email list building tactics.


The growth rate of your email list is calculated by comparing the number of new subscribers acquired during a specified period to the total number of subscribers you had at the beginning of that same period. Typically, this calculation is performed on a monthly or quarterly basis to provide a more accurate picture of your email list's growth trajectory.


A robust email list growth rate is an essential indicator of a successful email marketing campaign. However, keep in mind that the quality of your email list is equally important as its quantity. Aiming for organic growth by ensuring that your subscribers are engaged and interested in your content is crucial to improving the overall effectiveness of your email campaigns.


Furthermore, tracking your email list growth rate will enable you to segment your audience better, and send targeted and personalized content to specific groups of subscribers. This, in turn, can result in higher email open rates, click-through rates, and improvements in your overall campaign performance.


Therefore, it's crucial to keep an eye on your list growth rate and continually develop strategies to increase it while also ensuring that the quality of your subscribers is consistently high.


List Growth Rates Formula


List Growth Rates: [(Number of new subscribers - Number of unsubscribes) / Total number of email subscribers] x 100



What email metrics are no longer important?


Unsubscribe Rates


In the constantly evolving world of email marketing, keeping track of which metrics to pay attention to and which to disregard can be a daunting task. As marketing professionals, we all know that staying on top of the latest data-driven insights is essential for ensuring campaign success. However, it is equally important to be aware of the metrics that have become redundant or misleading due to changes in industry trends and consumer behaviors.


One such metric that is no longer considered a reliable indicator of email campaign success is the open rate. Previously seen as a crucial performance indicator, open rates used to be used as a measure of how many recipients opened an email compared to how many were sent. However, with the increase in preview panes, mobile email clients, and third-party user tracking blocking, these metrics have become less accurate. Many email clients now automatically download images within an email, thereby logging an “open” without the recipient actually viewing the content. This has led to open rates being overestimated, and hence, they have become a less reliable metric for gauging email effectiveness.


Similarly, click-through rates (CTRs) are no longer considered the sole metric for determining email success. While they are still useful, CTRs fail to take into account the true impact of email campaigns. Recipients may click through an email, but not always convert to a customer. Clicks also don't measure the impact on branding or awareness-building, which may lead to future conversions.


In conclusion, while open rates and click-through rates are still important metrics in email marketing, they must be looked at in conjunction with other KPIs to provide a more complete picture of the effectiveness of an email campaign. As industries evolve and consumer behavior changes, there will always be new metrics to pay attention to and old ones to discard, making it vital to stay up to date with trends and insights. Ultimately, what matters most is creating campaigns that are relevant, valuable, and engaging to the people on your list.



🔹 Conclusion:


In summary, understanding email campaign performance indicators is crucial for any business that utilizes email marketing as a key component of their marketing strategy. By tracking and analyzing important metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, bounce rates, conversion rates, and ROI, businesses can gain valuable insights into the effectiveness of their email campaigns and make data-driven decisions to improve their marketing efforts.


It is important to note that email marketing is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and what works for one business may not work for another. For this reason, it is imperative to continually track and analyze email campaign performance indicators to gain a better understanding of what resonates with your particular audience and adjust your strategy accordingly.


Implementing the learnings from this guide can make a significant difference in the success of your email marketing campaigns. By focusing on key metrics and making data-driven decisions, businesses can increase their ROI and maximize the impact of their email marketing efforts.


Moreover, keeping track of your email campaign performance indicators is not an option but rather a necessity. Numbers don't lie, and they are an excellent tool to measure your email marketing strategy's success. Neglecting this aspect could mean that you are missing out on valuable information that can help you make better marketing decisions and improve your return on investment.


If you haven't already, it's time to start tracking, analyzing, and optimizing your email campaign performance indicators seriously. By doing so, you can create more effective email campaigns and achieve your marketing goals. It may take time and effort, but the results are worth it.


In conclusion, email campaign performance indicators are vital to creating successful email marketing campaigns. By tracking and analyzing these metrics, businesses can improve their ROI and make more informed marketing decisions. So, take action today, and start optimizing your email marketing strategy!



📜 Related article:

◾ How to increase the ROI of email marketing

◾ 6 Ways to Increase Sales with Email Marketing

◾ Pros and cons of email marketing as a source of leads